Should We Share Knowledge or Protect It? A Thoughtful Ethical Dilemma
Elsayed ZewayedBetween the Ethics of Knowledge and the Right to Protect It.
Before we ask whether knowledge should be shared, we have to ask what knowledge really is. Is it just a piece of information? Or is it something deeper—something gained through time, effort, mistakes, and personal experience?
Reading about how to swim is not the same as being in the water. Watching a tutorial on design doesn’t mean you can lead a creative team. Knowledge isn't just data—it’s the connection between experience, context, and understanding. And that’s why some people feel protective of it.
2. Knowledge as a Public Right
Many believe knowledge is a right that should be shared with everyone. This idea fuels educational systems, free online courses, open-source software, and platforms like Wikipedia. It comes from the belief that when we share what we know, we build stronger societies, smarter generations, and faster innovation.
Throughout history, progress happened when ideas were shared. Scholars in the Islamic Golden Age translated Greek texts and made them available to others. Scientists published their findings so others could learn and improve upon them. Open knowledge helped cure diseases, build cities, and send rockets into space.
3. Knowledge as a Personal Investment
But what about knowledge gained through sacrifice? Time, money, effort, trial and error—these are the currencies of personal experience. For many creators, freelancers, and entrepreneurs, their “know-how” is what sets them apart. It's their edge in a competitive world.
In this view, knowledge is a product. It’s like a formula that took years to develop. And giving it away for free feels like handing over the keys to your workshop. This doesn’t mean being selfish—it means recognizing the value of hard-earned insight. You can be generous without giving away your tools.
4. When to Share, When to Hold Back
So where’s the balance? Maybe the answer is not black or white. Maybe we don’t have to share everything—or hide everything. There’s a middle ground: sharing basic knowledge to help others grow, while protecting the deep, personalized strategies that define your work.
Think of a chef. They may share recipes, but they won’t always reveal their secret techniques. A developer may open-source code, but keep their optimization tactics private. This isn’t greed. It’s survival.
5. Public Opinion: Generosity or Exploitation?
There’s also a social pressure to “give back.” People online might say, “If you don’t share, you’re selfish,” or “Knowledge belongs to everyone.” But sometimes, sharing too much leads to being copied, undervalued, or ignored.
On the flip side, hiding everything can make you isolated, unapproachable, or distrusted. So creators often walk a thin line between being generous and being taken for granted.
Some share because they genuinely want to help. Others hold back to protect their craft. Both choices are valid—as long as they come from intention, not fear.
6. The Big Question: What Do You Believe?
So we ask you: Should everyone who knows something be required to teach it? Or is it fair to protect the knowledge you’ve worked hard to build?
Should knowledge be treated like air—free and for all? Or more like gold—rare, valuable, and sometimes protected?
This isn’t a debate about right or wrong. It’s a reflection on how we see knowledge, value effort, and decide when to share our minds with the world.
A Personal Philosophy
In the end, maybe the best approach is balance.
Teach what uplifts others. Share what inspires growth. But also protect what defines your craft. You don’t owe the world every step of your journey—only the wisdom you're willing to give.
Because in the age of endless content, it's not the volume of knowledge that matters. It’s the depth.
......